I agree with you on that, I thought at first ruben was better and I loved his face expressions and smile... And clay kinda irritated me in the gay fashion and his facial expressions... but recently i heard them both sing without actually watching them and I definitly though that clay was better singer... I actually liked Kimberly, not Kimberly Locke but the other one.... I heard she was doing Playboy... which I don't think was smart to do right away, she could of waited a bit, since its a kids show.