Dade WiFi plan

[Guest speedway]

Posted on Sat, Jul. 15, 2006

MIAMI-DADE COUNTY

Dade WiFi plan aims to bridge digital divide, bring Net to all

Miami-Dade officials are considering providing Internet access across the county, as more governments believe wireless service is a utility.

BY JOSEPH TARTAKOFF

jtartakoff@MiamiHerald.com

Miami-Dade officials want to provide affordable wireless Internet access across the entire county. But it's an expensive and untested technology, an expert warned Friday.

At the first meeting to discuss the plan, Mayor Carlos Alvarez -- who unveiled the initiative in February -- said it could ''erase'' the ''digital divide'' in the area. School Board Member Ana Rivas Logan took Alvarez's words one step further.

''This will definitely help us to close the achievement gap,'' she said.

But there's a gap between the expectations of elected officials and the ability of industry to deliver on them, said Daniel Aghion, the executive director of the Wireless Internet Institute in Boston.

Increasingly, governments believe wireless Internet is a utility, just like electricity, and Miami-Dade is among a ''few hundred'' across the nation that are looking into providing it. But Aghion said few cities have actually deployed the networks and ``a lot of . . . experiments will probably not go as planned.''

Wireless technology allows computer users to connect to the Internet without the need of a phone line or a cable connection. For WiFi to work, the computer must have a wireless card -- common on laptops but less so on desktops -- and be within range of an access point.

Aghion said it's not profitable for municipalities to provide low-cost wireless. Therefore, the county should focus first on saving money by using it to boost employee productivity. A secondary benefit, he said, could be public access.

That did not sit well with Logan, who said she teaches computer classes in South Florida where some students don't know how to turn on a computer.

When William Talbert, the committee's chairman and president of the Greater Miami Convention and Visitors Bureau, asked for a cost estimate for constructing the network across the county's 2,000 square miles, Aghion hesitated.

''I'm not sure you'd want to,'' he said.

Aghion said it could cost more than $100,000 per square mile just to set up the network. That means a system could cost upwards of $200 million in the county.

However, Ira Feuer, a special assistant to the mayor, said afterward it could be closer to $150 million. It's possible that private partners could foot some or even the entire bill.

Alvarez hopes to begin implementing the plan within the next two years.

''I understand there will be a lot of challenges ahead,'' he said. ``I added an extra year because I know we would be breaking ground in a lot of areas.''

The committee will sponsor a number of focus groups and reconvene in September.

Meanwhile, a separate plan to provide free wireless Internet access in Miami Beach is advancing.

Gladys Acosta, the IT director for Miami Beach, said the city was designing its network. She said it had been difficult to identify city-owned buildings, poles and streetlights where the system's infrastructure could be built.

Both Broward and Palm Beach counties are also considering countywide wireless systems, according to Ralph MacNamara, an attorney who represented iCoast, a South Florida technology trade group, at the meeting.

[Guest jbit]

This is the key phrase ...

But there's a gap between the expectations of elected officials and the ability of industry to deliver on them, said Daniel Aghion, the executive director of the Wireless Internet Institute in Boston.

I have to fight this eveyday at work

[Guest pod]

The industry can deliver if you pay them. That's what it comes down to. The city or county wants it for nothing.

Looks like the Beach is doing it smart though (for once), whereas they are deploying it in public areas, as most people have their own access at home, and they're also making the 'primary' use for government services, and leaving it open to the public as a side benefit...i.e. the cops all use this slapped-together radio system for their laptops, now with the Wi-Fi, they can get the latest info and such on the perps more efficiently.

[Guest jbit]

The industry can deliver if you pay them. That's what it comes down to. The city or county wants it for nothing.

Anything is possible in the IT world, just because you can do something doesn't necessarily mean you should though. Leaving any wireless network that big wide open is a virtual pandoras box of potential problems. Especially if your planning for local government resources to share the same space as the dude next door. I hope they've got a fat budget for a bunch of security engineer's.

[Guest pod]

It'll be interesting to see how well it works.

[Guest macboy]

The problem I have is that if Dade County is doing it as well, I don't want to be taxed twice for this since Miami Beach is getting ready to roll out their service this September.

Also, it's not as if there are a lot of great public spaces where I'd feel comfortable using my laptop in Dade without fear of getting jacked. Public park space is so minimal here, and many cafes and shops are already adding their own wifi hotspots without charging. Not sure if it's worth the expense to cover all of Dade. I think it should be up to each individual municipality.

Seriously, how many of you are pulling out your laptop on a sidewalk in Liberty City?

[Guest pod]

I'm sure in the "less desireable" areas, it will be more for civil and law enforcement use.

My idea would be to have public areas with Wi-Fi, and then let the government use the WiMax spectrum, especially for mobile applications.

[Guest macboy]

I'm sure in the "less desireable" areas, it will be more for civil and law enforcement use.

My idea would be to have public areas with Wi-Fi, and then let the government use the WiMax spectrum, especially for mobile applications.

Did you see something in the press recently about Colombia rolling out WiMax? I'm pretty sure it was Colombia.

[Guest jbit]

Croatia, Saudi Arabia, South Africa, and Taiwan all have WiMax in place. Basically places that dont have the fiber infrastructure already.

[Guest pod]

Yeah, it was Medillin i think.

In Third World nations, it's actually far more efficient for the telcos to go wireless from the outset since the gear and install costs are far cheaper.