rdancer Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 *Take from another board*Gandalf the White from Lord of the Rings, or Yoda from Star Wars who would in a fight? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
djmikedr Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 after seeing Episode 2, Yoda. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hotcheme Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 Originally posted by apotheosis after seeing Episode 2, Yoda. yoda, cause he can fight and use the force. gandalf just had magic. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hitokiri24 Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 yoda, cause he has Grovers voice Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
georgym Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 Im gonna go against the mold and say Gandalf the Wiz His type of magic wasn't just any type. He could control weather, and influence people's decisions by just looking at them Actually, for those who have read Lord of the Rings the Novel (not the film), that dude Bombadil was THE most powerful oracle i have EVER heard ~scifismurf Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
italianchris19 Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 Yoda would beat the hell out of Gandalf Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
siceone Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 Originally posted by rdancer *Take from another board*Gandalf the White from Lord of the Rings, or Yoda from Star Wars who would in a fight? Fucking Nerd Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
danamdkny Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 Yo DA, Yo Da, yo Da, Yo Da :tongue: :tongue: Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hotcheme Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 Originally posted by gmccookny Actually, for those who have read Lord of the Rings the Novel (not the film), that dude Bombadil was THE most powerful oracle i have EVER heard yeah, why'd they leave him out of the movie? he was a cool character... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kaydup Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 Ditka Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
siceone Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 obviously you people never read the lord of the rings The hobbit or the sillmarilion... The only time tom bombaldil is mentioned in the books is when he saves Bilbo and Samwise from the entwives and the Barrow wights I belive ( been seven years since I read them)There is also the adventures of tom bombadil which is awesome.. to make a long story short the Fellowship of the ring is basically set up as the new testament of the Bible where gandalf is jesusand frodo and the others are representative of mankind.. just to show you what I mean remember when Saruman ( the devil incarnite) Tempts gandalf to join him and look into the orb and then imprisions him in the top of the white tower.. is much like the temptation of christ by the devil to jump off the cliff .. gandalfs fight with the balrog which I wont get into since it's much more invovled than you think is much like jesus's death and resurection for the sake of the fellowship i.e. Mankind.. so to sum it up the silmarillion is likened to the Pentatuch (first 5 books of the bible)the fellowship and the hobibit is like the new testament The history of middle earth one and two and the adventure's of tom bombadil are like the middle books ( the books included in the old testament but not included in the Torah) so I would definately have to say Gandalf would kick Yoda's Ass seeing as he came back from death and all.. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hotcheme Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 Originally posted by siceone so I would definately have to say Gandalf would kick Yoda's Ass seeing as he came back from death and all.. yeahbut i can't remember gandalf winning any big duels. i mean, it is definitely good for him that he came back from the dead and all but that didn't really help with the ass-kicking. i still think yoda would win. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
siceone Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 Originally posted by hotcheme yeahbut i can't remember gandalf winning any big duels. i mean, it is definitely good for him that he came back from the dead and all but that didn't really help with the ass-kicking. i still think yoda would win. Gandalf Vs. The Balrog HELLO@!!Gandalf Vs. Saruman GANDALF VS. Legions upon LEGIONS or Urikaih At HELLS DEEP just to name the few I rememberoh and Yoda hasn't won any battles if you remember he actually LOST against Darth Tyranuss since he got away.. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hotcheme Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 Originally posted by siceone Gandalf Vs. The Balrog HELLO@!!Gandalf Vs. Saruman GANDALF VS. Legions upon LEGIONS or Urikaih At HELLS DEEP just to name the few I rememberoh and Yoda hasn't won any battles if you remember he actually LOST against Darth Tyranuss since he got away.. k true - i forgot that yoda lost.but gandalf didn't win against the balrog - he died!and he lost against saruman too! he jumped off the tower to get away - how is that winning.hell's deep - i don't remember the details of that. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cintron Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 Yoda would completely kick his ass. End of story. He has the power to crush his enemies' throat with no effort whatsoever. (as seen with Darth Vader.)He can fight while using the force to hurl lethal distracting objects at his opponent. (Cloud City, The Empire Strikes back)and most of all... yoda's wisdom is unrivaled. He's lived for hundreds and hundreds of years, TRAINING the BEST Jedi. dont even argue. everyone knows Yoda would find a chink in gandalf's armor. that's what Jedi are best at. even if Gandalf were to slay Yoda, he would only hasten his own demise. By striking down a jedi, you commit them to become part of the force, thus giving the Jedi who follows a greater power to draw from. There would be no way Gandalf can reverse that equation.His own power would eventually be his demise. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
siceone Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 Originally posted by hotcheme k true - i forgot that yoda lost.but gandalf didn't win against the balrog - he died!and he lost against saruman too! he jumped off the tower to get away - how is that winning.hell's deep - i don't remember the details of that. He didn't Die you just didn't read two towers hells deep happens in return of the king... thats why the question was would gandalf the white win against yoda hey beats saruman in the two towers as well and in return of the king I think not to sure Gandlaf the GRey probably wouldn't but white he surely would Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ou812 Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 This is very interesting banter, it's funny watching you people analyze this......................................on a side note, if anyone is interested in what the plot of "Star Wars 3: Fall of the Republic" is gonna be, here it is,http://www.sugarbombs.com/starwars3/section9a.htm Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hotcheme Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 Originally posted by siceone He didn't Die you just didn't read two towers hells deep happens in return of the king... thats why the question was would gandalf the white win against yoda hey beats saruman in the two towers as well and in return of the king I think not to sure Gandlaf the GRey probably wouldn't but white he surely would oh ok. i jsut noticed that it says Gandalf the White. I think i still say Yoda though. Just cause I never saw gandalf with hand to hand combat. And yes, I did read the whole trilogy - it took me a while so I forgot some details. I remember Hell's deep but I forgot what role gandalf had played in winning the battle.and he didn't beat saruman in return of the king - or if he did he was already reduced to an insignificant enemy by then. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cintron Posted November 12 Report Share Posted November 12 Originally posted by ou812 This is very interesting banter, it's funny watching you people analyze this......................................on a side note, if anyone is interested in what the plot of "Star Wars 3: Fall of the Republic" is gonna be, here it is,http://www.sugarbombs.com/starwars3/section9a.htm what else do we have to do on a rainy tuesday just trying to keep our lives colorful.thanks for the plot summary :-D i'm going to make bets with people now that i am omniscient Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
barvybe Posted November 13 Report Share Posted November 13 So much misinformation here regarding GandalfAs gandalf the grey- Saruman bests him- he defeats but doesn't kill the balrog which then falls into the chasm...gandalf gets pulled in after him.- later he kills the balrog and throws him down the mountain side BEFORE he becomes the white.As the white- saruman is much reduced and they have a contest of wills, not a battle.- at helps deep he doesn't really fight - he gathers up and army and brings them to the other's aidIn fact, he never actually fights against anyone from that piont on he simply advices and sorta coerces people (which is all he's supposed to do)btw Carl - JRR on several occasions denied that there was any connection to the Bible or to WWII in his books.(I actually got to study this shit in school for a while)As for who would win - in a sword fight Yoda. But in terms of a battle of wills i think gandalf. Yoda actually underestimates his openents time and time again...- Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
t0nythelover Posted November 13 Report Share Posted November 13 Without a doubt Gandalf would step on yoda like a little green grape. Gandalf has crazy magic powers that would wreck the force. Gandalf does not fight because he chooses not to, not because he can't. The whole matter of the ring has to be solved by the races of middleearth not him because he knows that when he passes away there will be no one to save earth so they must be prepared. Kinda like how Goku didn't try to kill Majiin Buu in Dragon Ball z for those of you who watch it. The best fighters don't always fight because they know future generations must be trained. Gandalf did not kill the Balrog but he stopped it on the bridge, but you must understand how powerful the Balrog is. Its a demon from a whole other age thats not middle earth, i guess it would be older earth or whatever. I think yoda would have trouble fighting a Balrog. He couldn't run from it or fight it with his lightsaber. If it was a swordfight yoda would win but gandalf is too smart for that. Yoda is mad powerful cuz hes crazy old and had 900 years to get his powers, Gandalf is not 900 years old but is still powerful. I don't think yoda would crush gandalfs throat, i think there both honorable enough to fight a pretty fare fight. And after Gandalf wrecks yoda hell smoke a pipe with some hydro. yeah boy!heres a good question, who would win in a three way grudge match between yoda, a hobbit, and the midget from jackass. oh and every five minutes a new fighter from bumfights enters the fight. i think id bet my money on yoda for this one. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
siceone Posted November 13 Report Share Posted November 13 Originally posted by barvybe So much misinformation here regarding GandalfAs gandalf the grey- Saruman bests him- he defeats but doesn't kill the balrog which then falls into the chasm...gandalf gets pulled in after him.- later he kills the balrog and throws him down the mountain side BEFORE he becomes the white.As the white- saruman is much reduced and they have a contest of wills, not a battle.- at helps deep he doesn't really fight - he gathers up and army and brings them to the other's aidIn fact, he never actually fights against anyone from that piont on he simply advices and sorta coerces people (which is all he's supposed to do)btw Carl - JRR on several occasions denied that there was any connection to the Bible or to WWII in his books.(I actually got to study this shit in school for a while)As for who would win - in a sword fight Yoda. But in terms of a battle of wills i think gandalf. Yoda actually underestimates his openents time and time again...- he may have denied it but there are some clear parallels there Big brother Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cintron Posted November 13 Report Share Posted November 13 as a side note,Goku DID come back and fight Majin-Buu. Gohan was absorbed, and Goku was forced to fuse with Vegeta. In the end it is Goku who hurls the Genki Dama at Majin Buu to destroy him.sometimes when you want the job done, you just have to do it yourself. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
rocksteadyct Posted November 13 Report Share Posted November 13 Gandal cus i like him more - yodas uglyand hotcheme - i didnt know girls read real books! I thought they only read those sex in the city type books! haha Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cintron Posted November 13 Report Share Posted November 13 Originally posted by rocksteadyct Gandal cus i like him more - yodas uglyand hotcheme - i didnt know girls read real books! I thought they only read those sex in the city type books! haha Danielle Steele novels. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.