This is only my opinion... I prefer PVD over Scribbles anyday. Like many people have already stated, PVD not only mixes up masterpieces that makes you "feel" the music, he also creates his own. If you look at his new CD Out There and Back, all the track are by PVD. I didn't really comprehend his brilliance until I saw him spin at Twilo a couple of weeks ago. Oh my God - The way he moves the crowd... the awesome vibe and happiness he creates... awesome!!! While i haven't seen DJ Scribbles spin live, his CD's and music lack "emotion and spirit." He does have a variety music genres that he plays, but personally it doesn't impress me (sorry Scribbles fans, to each their own). He reminds me too much of a high school DJ partying it up at a prom. Maybe he will spin at a club in nyc sometime soon so I can check out what you guys/gals have said about his live sets. Who knows, maybe I will be impressed. The main difference for me is that PVD (and others like Oakie, Carl Cox and sometimes S&D) really lets me feel the music... be a part of it. That's my 2 cents...